I agree, you are all probably aware that Hymn books were written primarily for singers (it comes in 4 parts,SATB) and it was not always designed with piano players in mind.
If you play most hymns as they are written, there is no way that they are going to sound great. Lots of people love traditional hymns but they do not always love the traditional harmonies.
Knowing how to play hymns that really sound alive & contemporary is where the "play by ear" skills are needed.
Take for example "What a friend we have in Jesus" this midi is played "as written"
http://www.learngospelmusic.com/media/download.php?pid=3052
& is a world apart from this version (played very skilfully by the very talented Ddw4e)
So both skills are needed & are equally as important imho.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3-6IWx8Lu0
Be Blessed
Casioman
I disagree.
The SATB in Hymnals are used by most organist who read. There is really nothing else out there for them. Maybe those of us in the pentecostal church dont use it, but there is more to church music than that. (You go to an A.M.E church for example, And they expect you to read)
Yeah its good to make the song contempory and add "phat" chords and "sick" runs, but every song or situation does not call for that. Take "Holy Holy Holy" for example. Look at the bass line. It is an integral part of that song. Yeah you could probaly chord it out, but you will lose all those important bass and harmony notes. It just wont sound right w/o it. And unless you have a good ear or you can read music, you wont do the song justice.
And do chords give you the proper rythm of the song? how do you know how long to hold each note? How do you know when to repeat certain parts etc. if you cant read music?
If you are a beginer, then ok. But if you are a paid church musician then you gotta step your game up and not rely on getting the chords to hymns when EASY sheat music is readily available.
Seriously, We got church musicians getting paid major money, but they cant name not one note on the staff. If you would take a little time to learn what the notes are, you could chord the songs yourself.
Sorry for ranting, and this rant isnt directed towards anyone in paticular.