Hello there guys back with another thread. I understand I am beginner, but I have been having minor problems when picking up songs by ear. It seems to me that my ear is not that well developed yet. For instance, when I play songs I try to listen and then play the melody notes that are being harmonizied and then I determine what chord it is but the melody note stays on top in the chord I play. Now, I dont harmonize every single note that is sung in the song perhaps a few and that is about it. But some times I listen to piano player playing different chords onhow to harmonize a note in the song and this comes to my mind that I cant voice chords the way a piano player voices his or her chords. But the one thing I do is play the melody note on top when forming some type of chord.
For example, lets just say that the song was in the key of C. And the person who is singing sangs starts singing a C note and then a D note and then ens on a G note. And on that G note the song has that G note where it is sustain for long period of time. Me as a guitar player on how to harmonize that G note, my choices could be a Eminor (E G B) where G is on top and Em7 (E G B D) where the G note is on top and G major (G B D) where G on top or a G sus4 (G A D) where the G note is on top or a C maj9 (C E G B D) where G is on top or a C major (C E G) where G is on top or C major7 (C E G B) where G is on top or a a Dm11 (D F A C E G) where G is on top. That is about all I can think of on how to harmonize that G note. But my point is am I doing something wrong here when it comes to songs and how they are written?
