i ,ist admit, when i first saw the title of this post, i completely didn't see the "ear" next to the "protection" in the title, and i was COMPLETELY throwed by what kinda topic Jam_Bass was tryin' to start....LOL. It wasn't until i clicked the link, that I saw that I missed the "EAR".
Whew!!!
Ha ha. Hmmm, curious as to what u expected since u clicked the link anyway. lol.
I've tried ear plugs, but those stuff just ain't for me, so i order ear muffs earlier this week.
What are u seeking protection from exactly? I guess different things bother different people. My ears are more sensitive to the high frequencies, more than just sheer volume itself, so i usually find myself needing to protect my ears when im near a drummer that says on the cymbals like they're going out of style, or when the highs on the board are turned way up so all the vocals either in the mains (if im in the audience) or in the monitors (on stage) are screeching. I usually just ball up a piece of tissue and sit it right in my ear. It hardly deadens the sound, but it muffles a lot of the highs which is a relief.
Sometimes when its volume thats a problem, sometimes i just gotta deal, but at my church i usually tell everyone to bring the volume down. But in some cases the best option is to just move, since the source is usually the drums or the organ leslie. There were times when i wasnt "required" to play (especially during shouts) and because the music was SOOOO loud, i just put my bass down, got up and walked away (either far off to the side or the back of the church) until they were done. When asked why I left, i simply say "y'all were way too loud. i like hearing." Usually they get it and the next time the volume is much lower.
I honestly think the majority of musicians are slightly hearing impaired because they subject themselves to this insanity on a regular basis. And because of such they play even louder, and increase damage even further.
I think the best, but more expensive, solution is to get in-ear monitors for the entire band. that way the volume of the mix is tailored for each individual and thus the sound can be less aggressive. Usually the #1 excuse for a loud musician is "i cant hear myself" and that solves this problem for everyone. But usually that involves putting everyone in the mix (not necessarily going through the house though) and not everyone is capable (having the equipment or having the know-how) of doing so.