I too am a Hymn lover, I have about 6 hymnals. The 2 Churches that i currently attend (Lutheran + COGIC) Both sing a lot of hymns, but the new church I'm playing for is into Choir and worship songs
some of my favorites:
Jesus paid it all
Blessed Assurance
I know his blood has made me whole
I'm Saved
I love Him Because he first love me
A mighty Fortress is our god
Rejoice ye pure in heart
Holy Holy Holy
Crown him with many crowns
Oh how i love jesus
Precious lord
YES LORD
All Hail the power of Jesus Name
You broght me lord/How much i owe/ lord u made me what i am
I need thee
Let all the people praise him
Christ the lord is risen today
Shine on me
In his safety
I could go on forever
If you playin for a Cogic church you better know ALL the hymns that you church sings in EVERY KEY or you will be embaressed